The change of the elixir recipe called personalization in the marketing witch's kitchen

1. We must begin the introduction of the recipe and ingredients of the magical potion with a brief historical overview.

2. From the perspective of our witchcraft, there are precisely two aspects: on one hand, technological (which we should narrowly interpret in the context of this post as the entirety of the internet and communication tools), and on the other hand, marketing history.

 

3. The first ingredient of our elixir: CX

4. With the spread of digital tools and services, their usability from the user's perspective quickly became a central question. By the mid-2000s, the focus on usability, which had already accumulated a library of literature by then, proved to be narrow. It was no longer enough to pay attention to functionality and ergonomics: the broader approach (yes, UX) already encompassed all aspects that influence the user's interaction with a product or service, including emotions, perceptions, physical and psychological reactions, behaviors, and outcomes.

5. From here, it was just one step for brands and marketing to 6. customer experience 7. (CX), which we can describe as a holistic approach where the user becomes a customer, and which places the 8. customer experience 9. at its center in such a way that it covers the entire spectrum of touchpoints where the customer can interact with the brand or service.

10. At these touchpoints, the quality between the brand (or service) and the customer –  11. primarily from the12. customer's 13. perspective – 14. will be decisive: that is, the customer experience. However, 15. this 16. experience 17. cannot be general (or at least not in the sense that solving an ergonomic problem can be). 18. The experience, and its quality, is a much more personal (personalized), unique, and subjective entity than anything else that our digital footprints reveal about us in the online space (and which CX naturally relies on).

19. The second ingredient of our elixir: RM.

 

Our elixir's second ingredient: the RM

1. From the perspective of our thought process and story, personalization can only be dated from the early 1980s according to the historical segmentation attributed to Richard S. Tedlow; I would like to highlight the „hyper-segmentation,” from which „true” personalization becomes essential in marketing in the fierce battle for customers.

2. With the help of extensive and previously unused data collection, marketers are now able to truly customize their offerings based on various factors such as demographics, interests, location, and much more.

3. This marks the beginning of true „relationship marketing” (RM): from when 4. the5. prices and services truly connect, and establish a personal relationship with consumers.. 6. Our first brew is therefore an elixir for brands that creates something truly unique for the consumer through personalized communication and a one-on-one relationship-based customer experience.

 

7. The basic formula of our elixir is: CX+RM=P

8. The two processes, which are not completely independent of each other, magically converge in the essence that powerfully dominates and controls today's digital marketing: 9. personalization. 10. We have thus moved from the problem of user-friendly tools and interfaces to the world of extremely personalized – personalized (P) – offers.

11. Our (digital) marketing toolkit now includes magical tools such as 12. personalized recommendations13. (on the pages), 14. personalized advertisements, 12. personalized recommendations15. (depending on where and at which point I left a page), 16. personalized messages, 12. personalized recommendations17. (whether push or DM), and ultimately: 18. customizable product(s) and 12. personalized recommendations19. service(s). servicedeceptions.

We might also think that we can brew a more effective and stronger elixir based on our recipe by simply providing a „larger” customer experience for a more refined „relationship marketing.” The sad fact, however, is that this is not the case. The excessive personalization has triggered a response in consumers against our miracle product: 12. personalized recommendationscustomization paradoxthrough. This is nothing but the tension between consumers' demand for personalized experiences and their privacy concerns.

The question is where this boundary lies: consumers want to receive good, useful product recommendations, as well as interesting program suggestions and everything else, but they do not want much, or everything to be known about them by the marketing that forms the basis of personalization.

 

The modified formula of the magic potion: CX+RM+DP+T = P.

We need to modify our formula to take into account the consumers' desired antidote, the complementary component, privacy (more precisely, the pill of protecting personal data – Data Privacy (DP)). Marketing cookbooks are coming out one after another on this topic, offering recipes to resolve the paradox caused by our elixir.

Based on the trend, it can be concluded that the future of personalization marketing, more precisely its marketers, will need to allow colleagues from the legal department into the witch's brew, so that while adhering to the constantly changing and updating data protection regulations, they can communicate their own personalization recipe (strategy) and elements of data collection as transparently (T) as possible to their users and customers in order to increase trust in their brand and service – thereby reducing the tension caused by the paradox in the customer.

Well, then we are done with this, we just had to slightly modify the recipe (adding a bit of personal data protection and a bit of transparency). Now let's prepare the first brew!

           

The result of the first brew: CX+RM+DP+T ≠ P

We did not get exactly what we expected; the result will cause some disappointment for experienced tasters. Personalized, yes, the result is difficult to grasp and define; its characteristics differ from our previous brews: it is not as transparent, a bit murky, and shows other, previously unidentified notes.

We need to take a closer look at what ingredients we used during the process. Traditional marketing communication spells and solutions have tried (and still try) to assist and influence consumer decisions with a wide range of persuasion and influence tools.

However, these recipes, once they cross the boundaries of persuasion and influence and attempt manipulation (such intentional misdirection that deliberately obscures the consumer and their preferences), can still be relatively clearly detected today and can be held accountable for deceiving consumers (and here we will set aside the length of legal and consumer protection procedures).

However, with the new generative AI tools, layers are emerging in brand-customer communication that frame the perceptions of the consumer, customer and fit them into a cohesive framework that makes it difficult or nearly impossible to judge whether manipulation is taking place. The main difference between traditional and the emerging marketing communication is that dynamicin its is.

Each advertisement, each personalized content, leaflet, landing page, newsletter (and we could list more) static in the sense that it is tailored to predefined patterns (I get something different if I left a cart, something different if I just showed interest in a program, and so on), but the tools offered by AI are „on-the-fly” dynamic, can take into account the identifiable intentions at that moment (what words I searched for a product, what contentú articles I read, how, in whatstyle I comment for example), but they also try to figure out my emotional states – and they adjust and generate the (currently only) linguistic (but later possibly even visual) content for each of these.

We need to incorporate this essential modification into our elixir formula, which we had not considered and has only recently become an essential element in our mixture: the applied technology, the CX and RM supported and based on generative AI.

Other ingredients may also be included in the elixir of personalization unnoticed.

 

 

The result of the second brew: CXAI+RMAI+DP+T ≠ P

This brew is not the real deal either. More precisely, we managed to brew something different than what we expected. The result is again not a pure personalization. More precisely: it has become personalized, but the question is whether it is truly tailored to the consumer's needsand requirements? The technological solutions behind personalization provide brands, and thus marketers, with tools that go beyond the classic concept of personalization, alongside the incredibly evolving machine learning.

What do I mean by this exactly? I mean that on the right side of our formula, it is not the pure and desired personalized experience that stands, but something else. But then what will this compound be?

The unique consumerso uniquely personalized (digital) world surrounds it with this magic brew that it loses the reference points provided by the community to judge: what it reads, receives, sees, is classic marketing communication aimed at persuasion, possibly influence, or something entirely different: manipulation…

In the age of „fake news,” mass media, and extremely personalized social media, the phenomenon of „filter bubbles” casts a shadow over all this in the field of marketing communication as well. There will be those who are happy about this, and there will be those, including myself, who are rather worried and cautious about the magical nature of the magic potion.

 

The final brew: CXAI+RMAI+DP+T = PM

We must declare that – as the (seemingly the same and unchanged) components have historically changed, – our elixir has also changed. Its effect has changed, we have already seen that, however, we do not yet have precise knowledge about its power and the long-term effects of its application.

It must be marketed under a new name, and until we manage to uncover all the risks of this new compound, let’s simply call our magic brew personalipulation-ation-(a mixture of personalization and manipulation). With this new concept, we want to refer to the hybrid property of our witch's kitchen's new compound, which is capable of blurring and washing away the boundaries between persuasion, influence, and manipulation.

Personalipulation – what is true, what is false?

I believe that in the near future, studies on the effects of this elixir will dominate the topic on most forums where personalization is the subject. I think it is important for us as marketers to be aware of the ingredients of our miracle solution offered to brands and services (more narrowly: the ingredients modified by AI), even if we can hardly be aware of its long-term effects. It may also be worth involving linguists, lawyers, and perhaps even philosophers in further experiments, so that we can modify (supplement) our recipe in such a way that we can extract manipulation from the new miracle solution:

CXAI+RMAI+DP+T+(?) = P

 

The image material used in the article: A DALL-E generated a unique series of images through witchcraft, witch's kitchen, elixir, personalization, and manipulation by recombining keywords multiple times.

The article was published as part of the METU and the Marketing Secrets blog collaboration.